The first important man to decide that the United States was a nation was Abraham Lincoln. In his inaugural address of 1861, he said the Federal Government in Washington in the District of Columbia was a “national” government. He won the Civil War and since then there has been no stopping the rush to find a “nation” where none can possibly exist. The central government of the “nation” has the right to function only in a district located in no state and thus it would be if it were not impossible the government of the “nation” without being itself a state. None of the 50 states can be “nations” since none of them have full sovereignty. A nation can not give up full sovereignty and be a nation and a government like the one in Washington that was not granted full sovereignty by the American Constitution can not be either a state or a nation. But Lincoln won the Civil War and gangs of historians not only concluded that all the many peoples who ever settled in “America” , a place that can not be located on any map of the world, were “Americans” but also that “America” was, going back hundreds of years, a “nation”. Some English settlers from Holland who settled in 1620 in Plymouth, Massachusetts, a speck on the North American continent 5000 miles from another part of the “nation” on the Hawaiian Islands, were “Americans” who founded the “nation”. Many other “Americans” coming from various locations from all over the world, settling all over a non-existent place called “America”, also were latter-day founders of the “nation”. Let’s not quibble over the details of how the “nation” came to be because it never came to be as a reality. Let’s just agree that every day on the public media when reporters call the totality of our complex political system a “nation”, they are just reiterating what our historians have been telling us for years, that we are a “nation”.
The concept of a “nation” is one good means of uniting the hundreds of different peoples living in the United States. But if you believe as do I that the devoted loyalty of the peoples of the fifty states of our union to the government in Washington DC is not only worthwhile but also essential to our unity and the unity of all the states of the globe, what can be worse than people who have been told for generations that they live in a “nation” taking their teachers seriously? What if Americans really believe they live in a nation and a presidential candidate comes along like Donald Trump whose bombastic rhetoric and notions reveal he believes also that he lives in a nation and intends to rule our union of states if elected as a nation? This would be Gotterdamerung. This would be the fall of Stalingrad to Hitler’s army in 1943. This would be the end of democratic worldwide civilization. Without the government in Washington uniting with its laws and policies and its power not only the 50 united states but also the states of the world and the world economy, there will be no world as we know it. We Americans created Washington but it doesn’t belong to just us anymore. It also belongs to the world. It is the guts of the world and without it continuing to function as both a federal American government and as a world government we will have no world. Donald Trump wants to make the United States a great nation. They can never be a nation and if they try to become one they will destroy their own unity and the precarious unity of the world. Many Americans now see a chance to really live in a nation like everyone else in the world. That is why Donald Trump is so popular.That is why his election would be a disaster.
Daniel McNeill
Daniel McNeill’s novella The End of All Beginnings is available at
Read it free on Kindle with a free app or buy it on Kindle for $1.99.
Also available as a book for $5.99.
A powerful and very dramatic exploration of love and relations between
a 70-year-old man and four women, two sisters 18 and 19, their mother
46, and a lesbian friend 22. It is full of well-written dialogues between the five
In various situations including sexual relations. The drama moves fast right
from the start and it is impossible not to read it as quickly as possible (it
can be read in less than three hours} to an ending that is totally unexpected
and explosive. A complex drama that moves with its own momentum towards
one liberating ending to all its beginnings.